Which Retirement Accounts Should You Withdraw From First? Understanding Withdrawal Sequencing

A retirement plan involves more than investments alone.
Let's talk about how the different pieces of your retirement plan can work together.

Key Takeaways:

  • The order you tap your accounts can materially affect the taxes you pay over time. Because taxable, tax-deferred, and Roth accounts are taxed differently, the sequence you use matters as much as the amount you take.
  • A commonly discussed starting order can provide a useful framework, but it isn't a hard rule. Taxes, your other income, and your goals can all change which account you should draw from first.
  • Taking distributions from retirement accounts before retirement age can create significant tax and financial consequences. Depending on the account, your age, and the reason for the distribution, early withdrawals may be subject to income taxes, additional taxes or penalties, and the loss of potential future growth.

A record share of Americans are pulling money from their 401(k)s before they even retire. In 2025, 6% of Vanguard’s retirement savers took a hardship withdrawal, up from 5% the year before and about 2% before the pandemic.1It’s an understandable move in a tight spot, but one that can carry meaningful consequences: depending on the circumstances, early withdrawals may be taxable, may be subject to a 10% additional tax, and reduce the amount remaining invested for future growth. In short, taking retirement money early can have significant tax and long-term planning consequences.

Before taking a retirement-account distribution, consider whether income taxes or an additional tax may apply. Age 59½ is an important threshold for many retirement accounts, although exceptions and account-specific rules can apply.2 Once you’re there, the bigger question is which account to draw from first. That order, often called withdrawal sequencing, can affect taxable income, future required distributions, and how different assets are used throughout retirement.

A Practical Starting Order for Withdrawals

Retirement money usually sits in three kinds of accounts, each taxed differently. Taxable brokerage accounts may generate taxes from interest, dividends, and realized capital gains, with the tax treatment depending on the type of income and holding period. Distributions from pre-tax traditional 401(k)s and IRAs are generally taxed as ordinary income. Qualified distributions from Roth accounts are generally tax-free.

A common starting order is to draw from them in this sequence:

  • First, taxable accounts, so your tax-advantaged accounts keep growing.
  • Next, tax-deferred accounts like a traditional 401(k) or IRA.
  • Last, Roth accounts, because qualified distributions can be tax-free and Roth IRAs are not subject to lifetime RMDs for the original owner.

The general idea is to consider current tax consequences while allowing tax-advantaged assets additional time to remain invested when appropriate. It can be a useful framework for discussion, though the appropriate sequence depends on the individual’s tax situation, income needs, account types, and goals.

When the Standard Order Should Change

The common order assumes a simple, steady picture, but most retirements aren’t that tidy. A few things can make a different sequence work better for you.

How Taxes and Other Income Change the Order

Using taxable accounts first may leave larger tax-deferred balances later, potentially increasing future required minimum distributions (RMDs). RMD starting ages depend on birth year under current law, and larger taxable distributions may affect an individual’s tax situation.3One strategy to evaluate is taking measured tax-deferred distributions, or considering Roth conversions, during lower-income years before RMDs begin.

Your other income matters too. In lower-income years, taking additional traditional-account distributions or evaluating a Roth conversion may result in a different tax outcome than doing so in a higher-income year. In higher-income years, using Roth or taxable assets may be worth evaluating because additional taxable income can affect marginal tax rates and, for some Medicare beneficiaries, income-related premiums. Coordinating withdrawals with your tax picture each year may create opportunities for more tax-efficient retirement income planning.

How Your Goals and Investments Change the Order

Your plans can also flip the order. If leaving assets to heirs is a priority, the tax characteristics of Roth accounts may be relevant to the withdrawal strategy. Beneficiaries may receive qualified Roth distributions income-tax-free, although inherited-account distribution rules still apply.

During periods of market volatility, investors may consider how their available cash reserves, asset allocation, liquidity needs, and tax circumstances affect withdrawal decisions. The appropriate approach will depend on the individual’s broader financial plan, and market recovery is not guaranteed. 

When a Blended Approach Makes Sense

For some retirees, a blended approach that draws from more than one account type in a year may be worth considering instead of following a strict sequence. Blending withdrawals may provide additional flexibility in managing taxable income.

For example, you might take enough from a traditional account to fill your lower tax brackets, then cover the rest from Roth or taxable accounts to avoid a higher one. Depending on the circumstances, this approach may help manage taxable income more deliberately than a rigid one-account-at-a-time sequence.

The right mix depends on your accounts, your income, and your goals, and it can shift from year to year. That’s why withdrawal sequencing is less a fixed formula than an ongoing planning decision that should be revisited as circumstances change.

Retirement Account Withdrawal Sequencing FAQs

1. Which accounts should I withdraw from first in retirement?

A common starting order is taxable accounts first, then tax-deferred accounts like a traditional 401(k) or IRA, and Roth accounts last. That order generally prioritizes taxable assets while allowing tax-advantaged accounts additional time to remain invested. But it’s only a starting point, since taxes, income needs, account characteristics, and goals may support a different sequence.

2. What is the recommended sequence for withdrawing money from retirement accounts?

The classic sequence is taxable, then tax-deferred, then Roth. It can be a useful starting framework, but the appropriate sequence may change based on projected RMDs, annual taxable income, spending needs, and other planning considerations. The appropriate sequence should be evaluated in light of your individual circumstances and broader retirement plan.

3. What is the best withdrawal strategy for 401(k) accounts?

Because pre-tax traditional 401(k) distributions are generally taxed as ordinary income, the timing and amount of withdrawals should be evaluated alongside your other taxable income and retirement needs. For some retirees, measured withdrawals during lower-income years before RMDs begin may be one strategy to evaluate. The applicable RMD starting age depends on birth year under current law. Whether earlier withdrawals are beneficial depends on current and projected tax rates, income needs, account balances, and other planning considerations.

4. Should I withdraw from taxable accounts before my IRA or 401(k)?

It can make sense, but not in every situation. Withdrawing from taxable accounts first may allow tax-advantaged accounts to continue growing, which is why it is often considered as a starting point. However, following that order too rigidly could leave larger balances in traditional IRAs and 401(k)s later in retirement, potentially resulting in larger RMDs and additional taxable income. In some situations, strategically taking tax-deferred withdrawals earlier may help manage taxable income over time.

5. Should Roth IRA assets be saved for last in retirement?

It can make sense in some circumstances. Roth assets can provide tax advantages because qualified distributions are generally tax-free, and Roth IRAs have no lifetime RMDs for the original owner. Whether they should be preserved for later depends on the broader plan. Roth assets may also offer favorable income-tax characteristics for beneficiaries, although inherited Roth accounts remain subject to applicable distribution rules. One situation to evaluate is whether Roth withdrawals in a higher-income year could help manage taxable income or exposure to income-related Medicare premiums.

6. Is it better to withdraw from one retirement account at a time or use multiple accounts?

For some retirees, using multiple account types in the same year may provide additional planning flexibility. Blending withdrawals may help manage taxable income across years and coordinate distributions with targeted tax ranges. Draining one account fully before touching the next is simpler, but depending on the circumstances, it may create less flexibility in managing taxable income over time.

Get Help Building Your Withdrawal Strategy

Which account you tap first, and how you coordinate withdrawals over time, is an important part of retirement income and tax planning. A thoughtful withdrawal strategy may help manage taxes, future required distributions, and the use of retirement assets over time.

At Goldstone Financial Group, withdrawal sequencing can be evaluated as part of a broader retirement plan. We can help analyze how different withdrawal scenarios may interact with income needs, taxes, required distributions, Medicare considerations, investments, and legacy goals as circumstances and rules change.

If you’d like a clear plan for which accounts to draw from and when, schedule a complimentary retirement review with our team.

 

Resources:

  1. CNBC: 401(k) Withdrawals Are at a Record High
  2. IRS: Retirement Topics, Tax on Early Distributions
  3. IRS: Retirement Plan and IRA Required Minimum Distributions FAQs

 

Disclosure:

Goldstone Financial Group, LLC (“GFG”) is an investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. This material is provided for informational and educational purposes only. The opinions expressed herein are those of GFG as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice.

Nothing contained in this material is intended to constitute personalized investment, tax, legal, or insurance advice, or an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security or insurance product. The information presented should not be relied upon as the sole basis for any financial decision and is not intended to address the particular needs, circumstances, or objectives of any individual. Individuals should consult with appropriate financial, tax, legal, or other professionals regarding their specific circumstances.

Ready For The Next Step?

Get In Touch With Our Retirement Advisors Today schedule a meeting today