Top Retirement Planning Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

A retirement plan involves more than investments alone.
Let's talk about how the different pieces of your retirement plan can work together.

Illinois is home to about 2 million residents age 65 and older, roughly 1 in 6 people in the state.1 Some of the most consequential retirement planning problems aren’t dramatic blowups.

They’re smaller planning gaps, an outdated beneficiary form, a spending estimate that never accounted for inflation, that looked harmless for years and only became obvious once the paychecks stopped.

The good news is that the mistakes we see most are common, predictable, and easy to fix once you know where to look.

Mistake #1: Retiring Without a Realistic Spending Plan

Plenty of people know their account balances down to the dollar but only have a fuzzy sense of what retirement will actually cost. In order to know if you’re ready, you need a solid number, built from these pieces:

  • Everyday living costs: Groceries, utilities, transportation, insurance, phone and streaming, household help, all the ordinary spending that doesn't stop when work does. Start from what your household actually spends now, rather than assuming retirement automatically shrinks the bills.
  • Illinois housing costs: Mortgage or rent, insurance, upkeep, and, this one stings in Illinois, property taxes. Illinois has the second-highest property taxes in the country, with an effective rate around 2%, so even a paid-off home still comes with a serious annual bill.2 Qualifying seniors may be able to lower it through programs like the Senior Citizens Homestead Exemption or the Assessment Freeze, but confirm your eligibility rather than assuming.
  • Lifestyle spending: Travel, dining out, hobbies, club memberships, trips to see the grandkids, whatever makes retirement feel like retirement. If it's part of the life you want, it belongs in the budget rather than tacked on as an afterthought.
  • Irregular big expenses: A new roof, a replacement furnace, another car, making the house more accessible, helping a kid with a down payment. These don't show up monthly, which is why a budget built only on monthly bills looks deceptively low.
  • Inflation: Today's number is just the starting line. Over a retirement that could run 30 years, groceries, property costs, services, and healthcare all creep upward, so the plan has to leave room for your costs to grow.

Mistake #2: Claiming Social Security Without a Broader Strategy

A lot of the retirees we meet have already decided when they’ll claim Social Security, often based on a gut feeling: they’ve hit 62, they want the check coming in, or they’d rather not touch their investments yet. Those are understandable instincts, but claiming is one of the biggest financial decisions you’ll make in retirement.

Claim at 62 and your monthly benefit is permanently about 30% smaller than it would be at your full retirement age; wait until 70, and it’s roughly 24% larger.3 That’s a difference you live with for the rest of your life, so the right answer depends on your health, your other income, whether you’re still working, and how long your money needs to last.

For married couples, it’s bigger than one check. The higher earner’s claiming decision also sets the survivor benefit, the amount the surviving spouse keeps after the first passes. Claiming early can shrink that safety net for whoever’s left. Because of that, we look at both spouses’ benefits together rather than one at a time.

The question isn’t how to grab a check as soon as possible. It’s how Social Security fits with everything else you’ve got, so it does the most work for your household over the long haul.

Mistake #3: Taking Withdrawals Without a Retirement Income Plan

You spend 40 years piling money into 401(k)s, IRAs, and brokerage accounts, and then, overnight, you have to turn that pile into a monthly paycheck. Without a system, people tend to just pull money out whenever checking runs low, which is a recipe for trouble.

A workable income plan usually comes down to a few moves:

  • Start with the gap rather than a random withdrawal number. Add up your dependable income, Social Security, any pension or annuity, and see what's left for your portfolio to cover.
  • Decide which accounts fund your everyday spending, so you know where your paycheck comes from instead of raiding whatever account is handy.
  • Keep big one-time costs, a car, a trip, a home project, separate from your regular withdrawals, so one expensive year doesn't accidentally reset your baseline spending.
  • Hold an appropriate amount of cash and relatively lower-volatility, accessible assets so that a surprise doesn't force you to sell investments at a bad moment.
  • Build some flex into the amount you pull, so you can ease off in a rough market or a high-inflation year.
  • Revisit that number as you go. The amount you withdraw in year one shouldn't be a formula you blindly repeat for the next 25.

Mistake #4: Underestimating Healthcare and Long-Term Care Costs

Healthcare estimates tend to look complete until we dig past the premium. What people miss is everything around it, the copays, the care Medicare skips, and long-term care. Here’s the fuller picture:

  • Pre-Medicare coverage: Retire before 65, and you have to bridge to Medicare on your own, through the marketplace, COBRA, or a spouse's plan. Those premiums can be steep, and they can make an early retirement date cost far more than you expected.
  • Medicare and supplemental coverage: Medicare itself isn't free or complete. Between Part B, a drug plan, and a supplement or Advantage plan, treat “I'll be on Medicare” as the beginning of your healthcare budget rather than the whole of it.
  • Cost-sharing: Even with good coverage, deductibles, copays, coinsurance, specialist visits, and outpatient procedures still cost you. Being insured doesn't mean care is free.
  • What Medicare skips: Dental, vision, and hearing are barely covered, so a crown, a set of hearing aids, new glasses, or a pricey medication can hit your budget harder than any premium.
  • Long-term care: This is the one that can break a plan. In Illinois, a semi-private nursing home room runs around $89,000 a year, and assisted living averages north of $60,000 at the time of this writing.4 Treat it as its own separate risk, because ordinary health insurance and Medicare mostly won't cover it.

Mistake #5: Carrying the Wrong Investment Risk Into Retirement

A portfolio built for your 40s often gets carried straight into retirement without anyone asking whether it still fits. But the job of your money changes the day you stop adding to it and start living off it, and your risk should change right along with it.

A few risk mismatches we watch for:

  • Too much stock exposure gets riskier once you're withdrawing instead of contributing, because a big drop lands while you're also taking money out.
  • Too much cash is the opposite trap. Play it too safe and your money may not grow enough to keep up with inflation over a 25 or 30-year retirement.
  • Too much concentration, in one stock, your old employer's shares, one sector, or a single property, ties too much of your future to one outcome.
  • Skipping rebalancing lets years of market moves push your portfolio into more risk (or less) than you ever signed up for.
  • Sequence-of-returns risk, a bad market early in retirement while you're withdrawing, can do lasting damage that the same downturn later wouldn't.
  • Reacting to scary headlines with big, sudden changes can lock in losses and derail a good plan at the worst possible moment. The fix is tying your risk to your actual withdrawal needs, timeline, and comfort level rather than the news cycle.

Mistake #6: Overlooking the Tax Impact of Retirement Income

Illinois doesn’t tax most retirement income: Social Security, qualified pensions, and withdrawals from 401(k)s and IRAs all get subtracted before the state’s flat 4.95% income tax applies.5 It’s one of the most retirement-friendly setups in the country.

The catch is that Illinois’s retirement-friendliness doesn’t affect your federal tax bill, and that’s where the planning really lives. A big traditional-IRA withdrawal to buy a car, remodel the kitchen, or help a kid stacks taxable income on top of everything else you earned that year, and that’s all federal.

Those choices ripple into the future, too. Depending on an individual’s circumstances, lower-income years may present opportunities to evaluate strategies such as Roth conversions or planned withdrawals. These strategies can have significant tax consequences and should be evaluated based on the individual’s circumstances and, where appropriate, in coordination with a tax professional. The mix of taxable, tax-deferred, and Roth money you pull from, and when, can shift your lifetime tax bill by a lot.

And it reaches beyond your tax return. A big withdrawal, Roth conversion, or realized gain can bump up your Medicare premiums a couple of years later, since those are based on your income from two years prior. It’s all connected, which is why we coordinate these moves instead of taking them one year at a time.

Mistake #7: Letting Estate and Beneficiary Plans Go Out of Date

We regularly meet retirees who did their estate planning years ago, checked the box, and never looked again. Meanwhile, families change, assets grow, and old documents drift out of sync with reality. A few things are worth a fresh look:

  • Wills and trusts: Make sure they still reflect your family as it is now, the right heirs, the current assets, any charitable wishes, and how you actually want things handled. Life changes; the documents should keep up.
  • Beneficiary designations: Assets with valid beneficiary designations generally pass according to those designations rather than under the terms of a will.
  • Powers of attorney and healthcare directives: Confirm the people you named to make financial and medical decisions are still the right ones, still around, and still willing to serve if it comes to that.
  • Account titling and trust funding: For certain trust-based estate plans, proper account titling and trust funding can be important to ensuring that assets are administered as intended. Payable-on-death and transfer-on-death setups need to match the plan rather than fight it.
  • Illinois estate tax: This is the big Illinois-specific trap. Illinois taxes estates over $4 million, far below the multimillion-dollar federal exemption, and it doesn't let spouses share the exclusion.6 Between a paid-off home, retirement accounts, and life insurance, more Illinois families cross that line than expect to, so it's worth checking where you stand.

We can spot where these pieces don’t line up and coordinate with your estate attorney, who handles the actual legal drafting and advice.

Biggest Retirement Planning Mistakes Among Illinois Retirees FAQs

1. What is a common retirement planning mistake?

Retiring without a clear, realistic picture of what their life will actually cost, then having no system for turning savings into steady income. Almost every other mistake gets easier to avoid once those two are nailed down.

2. What are some retirement decisions people may later regret?

For a lot of people, it’s claiming Social Security too early or underestimating how long retirement, and its costs, would last. Both usually trace back to not seeing the decision in the context of the whole plan.

3. What are two expensive mistakes most retirees make?

Underestimating healthcare and long-term care costs, and overlooking the federal tax hit of big retirement-account withdrawals. Either one can cost tens of thousands over time.

4. What is the biggest expense for most retirees?

Housing and healthcare usually top the list, and in Illinois, property taxes make housing especially heavy. Long-term care can dwarf everything else if an extended care event hits.

5. Does Illinois tax retirement income?

Generally, no. Illinois lets you subtract Social Security, qualified pensions, and 401(k) and IRA withdrawals before applying its flat 4.95% income tax, which makes it one of the more retirement-friendly states. Just remember that doesn’t lower your federal tax bill.

6. How should Illinois retirees account for property taxes in retirement?

Build the full annual property-tax bill into your budget, even on a paid-off home, since Illinois rates are among the highest in the nation. Then check whether you qualify for senior exemptions or an assessment freeze to bring it down.

7. How often should retirees review their retirement income and withdrawal plan?

At least once a year, and any time something big changes, a market swing, a health event, a large purchase, or a tax-law update. Your first-year withdrawal plan shouldn’t run on autopilot for decades.

8. When should retirees update their estate plan and beneficiaries?

After any major life change, a marriage, divorce, death, birth, or big shift in assets, and as a general check every few years. Beneficiary forms especially tend to get forgotten, and they override your will.

How Goldstone Helps Illinois Retirees Avoid These Mistakes

Notice the thread running through all of these: the mistakes rarely come from one bad decision. They come from good decisions made in separate rooms, a spending choice here, a claiming choice there, an old beneficiary form nobody revisited. A strong retirement plan gets your spending, income, Social Security, healthcare, taxes, and estate plan actually talking to each other.

That’s the work we do at Goldstone. Our team considers these issues together when helping clients evaluate their retirement plans. That can include reviewing retirement income needs, investment strategy, tax considerations, healthcare planning, and estate-planning objectives, and coordinating with a client’s other professionals when appropriate.

From there, we pull it all into one coordinated plan, income, investments, taxes, healthcare, and legacy, that keeps adapting as your retirement unfolds. If you’d like a clear read on where your own plan might have gaps, schedule a complimentary retirement review with our team.

Resources:

1) U.S. Census Bureau: QuickFacts, Illinois

2) Tax Foundation: Property Taxes by State

3) Social Security Administration: Retirement Benefit Amounts by Claiming Age

4) Genworth: Cost of Care Survey

5) Illinois Department of Revenue: Individual Income Tax

6) Illinois Attorney General: Estate Tax/a>

 

Disclaimer:

Goldstone Financial Group, LLC (“GFG”) is a registered investment advisor with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or qualification. This material is provided for informational purposes only. Opinions expressed herein are solely those of GFG. None of the information presented in this material is intended to offer personalized investment advice and does not constitute an offer to sell or solicit any offer to buy a security or any insurance product and is not intended to be used as the sole basis for financial decisions, nor should it be construed as advice designed to meet the particular needs of an individual’s situation. GFG does not provide legal or tax advice. The tax and estate planning information presented is general in nature and should not be construed as legal or tax advice. Clients should consult with qualified legal and tax professionals regarding their individual circumstances. Tax laws and regulations are subject to change. 

Any references to protection benefits or steady and reliable income streams refer only to fixed insurance products. They do not refer, in any way, to securities or investment advisory products. Annuity guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. Annuities are insurance products that may be subject to fees, surrender charges and holding periods which vary by insurance company. Annuities are not FDIC insured.

Ready For The Next Step?

Get In Touch With Our Retirement Advisors Today schedule a meeting today